Tuesday, April 10, 2012

21st Century Learners

The "big idea" I chose to research resources for is the "E" in STEM.... engineering! I think that this is a topic many elementary teachers may shy away from, but getting students motivated and involved in engineering is a powerful way to prepare them for the future.

One obstacle in science education, including engineering, is the challenge of motivating girls and helping them to view themselves as future scientists (Buxton & Provenzo, 2011). It is important to provide female role models for girls in the science classroom (Buxton & Provenzo, 2011). I think that this is important for both female and male students.... it is a great idea for the boys to also view the girls as equals in science because the boys in our classroom today will be the men in the workforce of the future!

The following web resources are useful tools for the science classroom - especially for those teachers looking to focus on engineering.


http://www.brainpop.com/

This site provides entertaining and enlightening videos for children in all content areas including science. However, teachers need a subscription to access the materials.

http://pbskids.org/designsquad/projects/index.html

I discovered this in my search and can't wait to introduce it to my students! Apparently there is a design show on PBS and this website is an extension of it. Students can upload their questions and design ideas. Getting students involved in designing provides opportunities for real life applications of engineering concepts.

http://www.engineergirl.org/

This website is geared toward girls as a way to inspire them to get interested in engineering.

http://www.npr.org/rss/podcast.php?id=510221

Podcasts are a great form of professional development for teachers and can be used in the classroom tot present information.


http://www.thefutureschannel.com/index.php

This site has some free videos as well as some that require a subscription. My math curriculum at school comes with a limited subscription to this site and I love the kid-friendly videos that show real life applications of math and science in action.

One physical science activity that I can do with my students is to use the PBS Design Squad website as a tool to motivate them to look for solutions to real life problems. This would be a great launching pad into the field of engineering! Small groups can choose one a several pre-selected problems or pinpoint their own problem. Then they will design a solution to the problem using the principles of engineering. Students will gain a sense of community by uploading it to the website.

I think that the challenges I might face are the same two challenges I face in all content areas: a lack of technology and a lack of background knowledge and skills. However, in order to rectify this problem I need to start someplace and I think engineering is an exciting branch of science that not only will engage students but prepare them to be 21st century citizens.

Buxton, C., & Provenzo, E. (2011) Teaching Science in Elementary & Middle School. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Exploring Heat Transfer

This activity was a good example of the type of inquiry based activity that can be conducted in the classroom with limited resources. It is a great place to start for teachers who do not have a lot of resources or are teaching students who do not have a  lot of background knowledge. Most students in my third grade classroom would have some type of background experience with heat transfer perhaps from working in the kitchen at home. This lesson has an obvious real world connection which also is an important motivating factor.

To conduct this inquiry, I used 4 identical mugs and the following 4 insulators: plastic wrap, waxed paper, aluminum foil, and a plastic lid that came from a soup mug designed for travel. I predicted the plastic lid would be the best insulator because it was the thickest material and it came from a mug that was designed for that purpose.



After 20 minutes, I recorded the temperatures of the water in each mug. The results were: plastic wrap 90.8 degrees; waxed paper 91.7 degrees; aluminum foil 92.5 degrees; and the plastic lid 90.7 degrees. The best insulator was the aluminum foil and the worst insulator was the plastic lid. I wondered if the plastic lid would have performed better if it fit the mug tightly. Since it came from a mug of a different size, it was not tight and unable to be secured by a rubber band like the other materials because it was not flexible. I thought the waxed paper might have insulated a bit better because of the coating. However, it was the second best.

Three methods of heat transfer are conduction, convection, and radiation (Enger, Ross, & Tillery, 2008). I think the 2 types of heat transfer involved in this lesson are conduction and convection. I believe that the aluminum foil did a better job of preventing heat transfer through conduction than the plastic wrap because it has less air spaces (Enger, Ross, & Tillery, 2008). The plastic lid most likely did not insulate against heat loss through convection because it did not fit tightly and allowed heat to escape as it moved from warmer to cooler air (Enger, Ross, & Tillery, 2008). 

Students would find this activity relevant to their real lives because it has many applications from cooking to clothing. Anytime teachers can make learning relevant, student participation and motivation is likely to increase!

Puzzled over Pendulums!

The question I chose to investigate was whether a lighter pendulum or heavier pendulum would come to rest first. I chose this question rather than the others because it is the concept that is the least familiar to me and I was curious to see what would happen. I thought that my own preconceived notions might interfere with my learning for some of the other activities.

I was not sure what to expect! I wavered in my prediction because I thought the heavier washer might continue to swing for a longer amount of time if it had a greater momentum due to its weight. However, I also thought that the smallest washer might swing for a the longest amount of time due to it being so lightweight. I honestly wasn't sure!

I tested 3 washers of varying sizes and weights. I looped the end of a string through the center and doubled the string. As I held the string, I tried to give each washer and equal push. I used the stopwatch on my cellphone to record how long each washer remained in motion. I tested each washer twice and the results are as follows: the lightest washer- 39.32 seconds and 44.84 seconds; the medium washer- 22.17 seconds and 26.35 seconds; and the heaviest washer- 25.46 seconds and 23.27 seconds.

In this case, the lighter pendulum remained in motion for a longer amount of time than the heavier pendulum. I believe this is aligned with Newton's second law of motion. However, during the first trial, the heaviest washer continued to swing for a longer time than the medium washer yet still stopped before the lightest washer. One thing I could have done differently is to conduct the activity for a third time to gather and compare more data.

I wonder how some of the challenges I faced in conducting this inquiry activity affected the results. For example, I tried to give each washer an equal push. However, I doubt that it is possible to be completely accurate in this instance and was not sure how to set up the activity differently to correct that. (Suggestions?)

Also, I am not certain how the diameter of the washers affected the outcome. For example, the small and medium washers felt about the same weight to me yet the small washer was approximately 1/2 inch in diameter and the medium washer was approximately 1 inch in diameter. Perhaps the diameter was a factor in the results? Obviously it would have been beneficial if I weighed each washer but I did not have the resources available to do so.

This is an activity that I easily could do with my students because it does not require a lot of resources. It would be a good opportunity for my third grade students to use their math skills as they time the pendulums to the hundredth of a second and use graphs to display their data. However, I am unsure if students at this level have the ability to grasp Newton's laws. In my school, science is a content area that tends to get the least amount of instructional time and Physical Science even less due to the fact that it is scheduled at the end of the year in the curriculum sequence map. I think that my students need more background knowledge to glean what they need to know from an activity like this.... however, this is a simple place to start building that knowledge for future years!

Sunday, December 11, 2011

The Clean Water Challenge

As I noted in my Lesson Reflection application, I think the biggest challenge of implementing this lesson was for the teacher! I'm sure we can all relate to the experience of getting excited about a new or interesting idea and then the lesson doesn't quite pan out in real life as we had hoped. Nonetheless, I enjoyed watching my students work together in cooperative groups to build models of the process of filtering water and relating it to groundwater.

This lesson was a structure inquiry lesson in which students were given the question and procedure, but not the solution (Banchi & Bell, 2008). Students worked together to test various types of sediment to build a filter that "cleaned" dirty water. Their learning was positively impacted by working together to find the solution to a problem that has real life applications. I believe the real life application is what makes this activity meaningful because the content of this lesson is something the students can relate to their everyday lives.

I also included possible extension activities that build connections to other content areas:

Language Arts: write or illustrate a response to a poem about water; write an original haiku about water; write fictional newspaper headlines and articles about a mysterious time when the Earth’s water disappears for one day.

Math: create and distribute a survey about water use – graph the resulting data using various forms of graphs; conduct study of units of measurement; create a probability tree about encountering different types of sea life on a snorkeling trip.

Character Education: design posters with water conservation messages; plan a fundraiser and adopt an endangered species of sea creature; write and illustrate children’s books about water conservation and read them to a kindergarten class as guest authors.

Social Studies: draft a letter to a senator or member of congress about an important issue regarding water conservation; invite guests from the community to speak about their careers involving water or water conservation (purifying plant, hydropower plant, etc.); conduct research about the way citizens in other countries obtain water including marking a map of the countries.

Science: simulate the geological formations in an aquifer by building an “edible earth parfait” (use chocolate chips for gravel, clear soda for water, etc.); build a terrarium to observe the water cycle’s role in sustaining life.

Music: Write and perform a song or rap about conserving the Earth’s water supplies, the water cycle, or groundwater.

Art: Illustrate a poster about the Earth’s water supplies; Create a bracelet depicting the stages of the water cycle.

Unfortunately, the challenge I faced in creating this blog is the same challenge I faced in implementing this lesson: a lack of available technology. Attached are some photos that demonstrate student learning in action as they build models of a water filtration system.




Sunday, November 13, 2011

5E's

I created a lesson entitled “Discovering Germs” which was adapted from several online resources. The objectives are that students will be able to recognize that microscopic germs exist on common surfaces and to assess the effectiveness of hand washing as a method of preventing germs.

This lesson was created to encompass the 5E’s: engagement, exploration, explanation, elaboration, evaluation. This is different from the usual way I plan lessons because the exploration leads to explanation. At our school, we usually teach a mini-lesson first and then move on to the exploration or lab activity. I think that the 5E’s structure of lesson planning is more effective in science because the focus is on the hands-on portion of the lesson and the other activities are extensions of the exploration.

I might have some difficulties implementing this lesson as planned due to a lack of technology resources at my school. I only have 3 student computers for 25 children and none of them are working at this point. This lesson could be enhanced through the use of Power Point presentations, video cameras, and interactive white boards. Unfortunately, at this time I do not have access to these tools. I believe this is one of the factors that accounts for the disparity between the performances of our school versus other schools in more affluent districts.




References

American Association for the Advancement of Science. (2009). Benchmarks online, Chapter 10. In Benchmarks for scientific literacy project 2061. New York, NY: Oxford University Press. Retrieved from http://www.project2061.org/publications/bsl/online/index.php?chapter=10
Spangler, S. (2011). Cover your mouth – germ science. Retrieved from: http://www.stevespanglerscience.com/experiment/glo-germ-and-giantmicrobes
Wagaman, J. (2008) The germy potato experiment. Retrieved from: http://www.suite101.com/content/science-lessons-at-home-a46242