This activity was a good example of the type of inquiry based activity that can be conducted in the classroom with limited resources. It is a great place to start for teachers who do not have a lot of resources or are teaching students who do not have a lot of background knowledge. Most students in my third grade classroom would have some type of background experience with heat transfer perhaps from working in the kitchen at home. This lesson has an obvious real world connection which also is an important motivating factor.
To conduct this inquiry, I used 4 identical mugs and the following 4 insulators: plastic wrap, waxed paper, aluminum foil, and a plastic lid that came from a soup mug designed for travel. I predicted the plastic lid would be the best insulator because it was the thickest material and it came from a mug that was designed for that purpose.
After 20 minutes, I recorded the temperatures of the water in each mug. The results were: plastic wrap 90.8 degrees; waxed paper 91.7 degrees; aluminum foil 92.5 degrees; and the plastic lid 90.7 degrees. The best insulator was the aluminum foil and the worst insulator was the plastic lid. I wondered if the plastic lid would have performed better if it fit the mug tightly. Since it came from a mug of a different size, it was not tight and unable to be secured by a rubber band like the other materials because it was not flexible. I thought the waxed paper might have insulated a bit better because of the coating. However, it was the second best.
Three methods of heat transfer are conduction, convection, and radiation (Enger, Ross, & Tillery, 2008). I think the 2 types of heat transfer involved in this lesson are conduction and convection. I believe that the aluminum foil did a better job of preventing heat transfer through conduction than the plastic wrap because it has less air spaces (Enger, Ross, & Tillery, 2008). The plastic lid most likely did not insulate against heat loss through convection because it did not fit tightly and allowed heat to escape as it moved from warmer to cooler air (Enger, Ross, & Tillery, 2008).
Students would find this activity relevant to their real lives because it has many applications from cooking to clothing. Anytime teachers can make learning relevant, student participation and motivation is likely to increase!
No comments:
Post a Comment