The question I chose to investigate was whether a lighter pendulum or heavier pendulum would come to rest first. I chose this question rather than the others because it is the concept that is the least familiar to me and I was curious to see what would happen. I thought that my own preconceived notions might interfere with my learning for some of the other activities.
I was not sure what to expect! I wavered in my prediction because I thought the heavier washer might continue to swing for a longer amount of time if it had a greater momentum due to its weight. However, I also thought that the smallest washer might swing for a the longest amount of time due to it being so lightweight. I honestly wasn't sure!
I tested 3 washers of varying sizes and weights. I looped the end of a string through the center and doubled the string. As I held the string, I tried to give each washer and equal push. I used the stopwatch on my cellphone to record how long each washer remained in motion. I tested each washer twice and the results are as follows: the lightest washer- 39.32 seconds and 44.84 seconds; the medium washer- 22.17 seconds and 26.35 seconds; and the heaviest washer- 25.46 seconds and 23.27 seconds.
In this case, the lighter pendulum remained in motion for a longer amount of time than the heavier pendulum. I believe this is aligned with Newton's second law of motion. However, during the first trial, the heaviest washer continued to swing for a longer time than the medium washer yet still stopped before the lightest washer. One thing I could have done differently is to conduct the activity for a third time to gather and compare more data.
I wonder how some of the challenges I faced in conducting this inquiry activity affected the results. For example, I tried to give each washer an equal push. However, I doubt that it is possible to be completely accurate in this instance and was not sure how to set up the activity differently to correct that. (Suggestions?)
Also, I am not certain how the diameter of the washers affected the outcome. For example, the small and medium washers felt about the same weight to me yet the small washer was approximately 1/2 inch in diameter and the medium washer was approximately 1 inch in diameter. Perhaps the diameter was a factor in the results? Obviously it would have been beneficial if I weighed each washer but I did not have the resources available to do so.
This is an activity that I easily could do with my students because it does not require a lot of resources. It would be a good opportunity for my third grade students to use their math skills as they time the pendulums to the hundredth of a second and use graphs to display their data. However, I am unsure if students at this level have the ability to grasp Newton's laws. In my school, science is a content area that tends to get the least amount of instructional time and Physical Science even less due to the fact that it is scheduled at the end of the year in the curriculum sequence map. I think that my students need more background knowledge to glean what they need to know from an activity like this.... however, this is a simple place to start building that knowledge for future years!
No comments:
Post a Comment